The reviews are in for Now You See Me Live, the magic show spun off from the Lionsgate heist films, which began performances at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on November 11 and is playing a limited holiday engagement. Created by Simon Painter, the producer behind The Illusionists, with Adam Trent, it puts four “Horsemen” on stage, Matthew Pomeroy, Darcy Oake, James More and Gabriella Lester, with Eden Choi as special guest. Most critics see the film connection as little more than a name on the poster. Where they differ is on the magic, which the independent sites mostly enjoy and Time Out New York and TheaterMania find too familiar.
The verdict: six outlets have reviewed it so far, and three put a score on it: four out of five from StageZine and The Front Row Center, three out of five from Culture Sauce. Time Out New York files it as not recommended, and TheaterMania is just as cool, both finding the tricks familiar and the execution uneven. Most agree the films are little more than a name on the poster, and several single out Darcy Oake’s scorpion and underwater escape and Eden Choi’s sleight of hand as the highlights.
What are critics saying about Now You See Me Live?
TheaterMania
"Now You See Me Live Lacks the Magic of Broadway"
Reviewer: Francisco Mendoza
Francisco Mendoza finds no story and no thread between the acts, and no real link to the films beyond a couple of passing mentions.
"So why use the Now You See Me name in what is basically an episode of America’s Got Talent?"
He calls the results hit-or-miss: Oake’s live scorpion made him gasp and More’s teleportations delighted him, but he could often tell how a trick was done, the finale included.

Time Out New York
"Five magicians take the stage in a pageant of mystification by the creators of The Illusionists."
Reviewer: Adam Feldman
Adam Feldman, who files the show as “not recommended”, points to stale jokes from the host and small slips of execution that took the shine off several effects.
"Now You See Me Live is not on the level of the city's best magic shows, but it is also more affordable"
He does credit real skill and suspense, notably Oake’s underwater lock-picking, and calls Eden Choi’s brief card-and-ball set an oasis of beauty.
StageZine
"Holiday magic is back"
Reviewer: Scott Harrah · 4 out of 5
Scott Harrah, a veteran of the earlier Illusionists seasons, notes how closely this one resembles them, and finds Pomeroy a lively host.
"I anticipated a flashy, entertaining spectacle, and I wasn’t wrong."
Oake’s scorpion and Houdini-style water escape are his jaw-droppers and Choi his favorite, though he finds Lester’s and More’s big illusions less memorable. He calls it great family-friendly fun.

The Front Row Center
"A Little More Than Magic"
Reviewer: Carmin Caterina · 4 out of 5
Carmin Caterina went in without having seen the films and came out won over, enjoying how much of the evening turns the audience into part of the act.
"Now You See Me Live was vibrant, exciting, captivating and, in some ways, not at all what I expected."
One audience-wide trick did not work for her, and some of the stunts left her genuinely anxious about how much real risk was involved.
Culture Sauce
"conjures a slick but familiar night of magic"
Reviewer: Thom Geier · 3 out of 5
Thom Geier thinks this is the film franchise that makes most sense on stage, and finds the five performers polished and the show fast-moving.
"Even skeptics who know the “secret” will admire the skills these artists display."
His reservation is familiarity: if you have seen a magic act in the last decade, you have seen versions of many of these tricks, and the highlight of his evening came from a young volunteer rather than from the Horsemen.

New York Theatre Guide
"a mesmerizing illusion spectacle"
Reviewer: Kyle Turner
Kyle Turner sees the film tie-in as mostly cosmetic, but rates what lies underneath as a very solid magic show, with live camera feeds bringing the close-up work to the whole house.
"Now You See Me Live sometimes feels like a Vegas show retrofitted to a Broadway stage."
He still finds the escapes, the scorpion swallow and the card work legitimately impressive, and thinks the show anticipates a cynical New York crowd well.
Production photographs by Jeremy Daniel.
For more on the production, see our first look at the Horsemen on stage at the Al Hirschfeld.
Now You See Me Live is playing at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre, 302 West 45th Street, through January 3, 2027.








