James Monroe Iglehart, Ana Gasteyer and Isabelle McCalla sing on The Nice List studio cast album

Artwork for The Nice List studio cast recording and the single It's Always a Holiday, from Center Stage Records A cartoon Santa shrugs against a bright red screen as James Monroe Iglehart sings the first track out from The Nice List, a holiday musical whose studio cast album arrives from Center Stage Records on November 27.

Phoebe Kreutz wrote the book and lyrics and Gary Adler the music. Santa is called away from the North Pole on business, and two elves are left to sort out the Nice and Naughty Lists. The show began as a digital musical in 2020 and reached the stage in 2025 at Bristol Riverside Theatre in Pennsylvania.

The single, It's Always a Holiday, lands on streaming services on November 20, a week before the full album. The label's official video sets Iglehart's vocal against the album cover and the show's animated Santa, who takes up half the frame.

If the video does not load, watch it on YouTube.

Iglehart, a Tony winner for Aladdin, plays Santa. He is one of the performers carried over from the 2020 digital version, along with Jennifer Barnhart as Cookie and Don Darryl Rivera as Marzipan. The rest of the album cast is Ana Gasteyer as Raisin, Isabelle McCalla as Gumdrop, Joshua Dela Cruz as Chestnut and Nick Kohn as Fruitcake.

Michael Croiter produced the recording, with Telly Leung, Joey Monda and Alan Muraoka as executive producers. It is released by Center Stage Records with Yellow Sound Label, and pre-saves are open on the album's pre-save page.