Review Roundup: DOWNSTATE at the Booth Theatre

Cassie Beck, Thomas Sadoski and Francis Guinan in Downstate at the Booth Theatre. Photo by Emilio Madrid The reviews are in for Downstate, Bruce Norris’s play about four men living in a group home for registered sex offenders in downstate Illinois, which opened at the Booth Theatre on November 15 in a new production directed by Joe Mantello. It reaches Broadway after Steppenwolf in 2018, the National Theatre in London in 2019 and Playwrights Horizons in 2022, with K. Todd Freeman and Francis Guinan back as Dee and Fred, and Thomas Sadoski, Liza Colón-Zayas, Al’Jaleel McGhee, Adrian Martinez, Cassie Beck and Ivy Wolk new to the company. Most of the critics come away impressed and the acting is praised almost everywhere; the dissent is over how fairly Norris treats Andy, the one victim we meet, and whether this staging hits as hard as the 2022 one.

The verdict: twelve outlets have reviewed it so far, thirteen critics in all, and only four of the outlets put a score on it: five stars from Time Out New York and from both New York Stage Review critics, four out of five from The Guardian and four out of four from the New York Post. The unrated notices run from raves at TheaterMania, Deadline and TheWrap to the real unease of Helen Shaw in The New York Times, and two critics who saw the 2022 Off-Broadway production, at Exeunt and TheWrap, think it carried more charge then. On the acting there is close to no argument: K. Todd Freeman, Francis Guinan and Thomas Sadoski are praised almost everywhere, and Joe Mantello's staging and Scott Pask's shabby group home come in for steady credit.

What are critics saying about Downstate?

The New York Times

"How Much Should Sex Offenders Be Punished?"

Reviewer: Helen Shaw

Helen Shaw is the most uneasy of the critics, admitting that more than one moment turned her stomach, among them a burst of applause from her audience when a character says sex offenders should simply choose death.

"Norris, king of feel-bad comedies, does have compassion, but he distributes it in unusual, deliberately shocking ways."

She credits Norris with compassion, but finds he hands it out in deliberately shocking places, and that he goes after liberal pieties as readily as after puritans.

Read Helen Shaw’s full review in The New York Times

The Guardian

"Razor-sharp tragicomedy set in a home for sex offenders"

Reviewer: Owen Myers · 4 out of 5

Owen Myers calls Mantello's staging a showcase of acting, singling out Liza Colón-Zayas as an electric probation officer, and finds the humor as grim as it is wickedly funny.

"Downstate is a blistering examination of what being treated as scum does to a person’s psyche."

He argues that the play never excuses the men, but does the still-radical thing of treating them as human beings rather than bogeymen.

Read Owen Myers’s full review in The Guardian

Liza Colón-Zayas, Al’Jaleel McGhee, Francis Guinan, Adrian Martinez and K. Todd Freeman in Downstate. Photo by Emilio Madrid

Vulture

"Downstate Is a Harrowing Moral Wrestling Match"

Reviewer: Sara Holdren

Sara Holdren regrets a marketing campaign that sells the play on controversy and, she thinks, primed her audience to laugh in the wrong places, but calls the production a showcase for its actors.

"Downstate forces us to stand at the shore of our own reservoir of mercy, to consider how deep it really goes."

She praises K. Todd Freeman's masterfully calibrated Dee and Thomas Sadoski's fixated, vulnerable Andy, while wondering whether Norris takes a few too many bites out of Andy and his wife.

Read Sara Holdren’s full review at Vulture

Deadline

"Provocative Play About Sex Offenders Questions The Nature Of Forgiveness"

Reviewer: Greg Evans

Greg Evans calls it commandingly written and shrewdly directed, compelling from start to finish even though very little actually happens, with Scott Pask's group home flawlessly designed.

"Downstate dares us to forgive the unforgivable, challenging the very concept of grace."

He dismisses the charge that the play praises its subjects: he came away convinced that none of the four men should live unrestricted, which is exactly the discomfort the play is after.

Read Greg Evans’s full review at Deadline

Thomas Sadoski, Ivy Wolk, K. Todd Freeman and Al’Jaleel McGhee in Downstate. Photo by Emilio Madrid

TheaterMania

"Downstate Is the Most Dangerous Play on Broadway"

Reviewer: Zachary Stewart

Zachary Stewart, who was astounded by the 2022 Off-Broadway run, finds the new production sturdy and its revamped design a picture of salvaged dignity.

"Norris is the demolition expert of the American theater, giving audiences an up-close look as our simplistic fairy tales implode onstage."

He calls Freeman's Dee a heroic performance and is riveted by Sadoski, and he reads the play's arrival on Broadway as a sign that deeply unpopular views can still get a hearing.

Read Zachary Stewart’s full review at TheaterMania

TheWrap

"Bruce Norris Proves Again That He’s a Great Playwright"

Reviewer: Robert Hofler

Robert Hofler admires Norris's construction and his one-liners, and singles out Adrian Martinez, who turns Felix's story into real tragedy.

"Obviously, this is a rave review. But there are caveats."

His caveats: he found the 2022 production even more disturbing, and he thinks Al’Jaleel McGhee and Ivy Wolk push too hard for laughs.

Read Robert Hofler’s full review at TheWrap

A scene from Downstate at the Booth Theatre. Photo by Emilio Madrid

Time Out New York

"Downstate brings monsters to life"

Reviewer: Adam Feldman · 5 out of 5

Adam Feldman calls the play shattering and necessary, a piece that uses imagination, nuance and irony to open a conversation that seems impossible anywhere else.

"This play might very well make you uncomfortable. Brace yourself and go."

He praises Mantello's intelligence, calls Freeman supreme and Francis Guinan surpassingly gentle, and finds Colón-Zayas and Sadoski registering even more strongly than before.

Read Adam Feldman’s full review at Time Out New York

New York Post

"Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway"

Reviewer: Johnny Oleksinski · 4 out of 4

Johnny Oleksinski calls it the best new play on Broadway and one of the finest works of the decade, and praises Norris for refusing to tell the audience how to feel.

"In short, it’s what everybody wants in a play, about people nobody wants in their community."

He finds the acting as muscular as the writing, especially from Freeman and Sadoski, and describes Mantello staging each scene as a cage match.

Read Johnny Oleksinski’s full review in the New York Post

Liza Colón-Zayas and the residents of the group home in Downstate. Photo by Emilio Madrid

New York Stage Review

"The Disturbing Humanity of the Inhuman"

Reviewer: Roma Torre and Michael Sommers · both 5 out of 5

Both of the site's critics give it five stars. Roma Torre calls it some of the finest acting you are likely to see on Broadway, with Sadoski's painfully nuanced Andy and Freeman's bravura Dee at the top of the list.

"Downstate is not an easy play to watch. But it is a stunning achievement, meticulously constructed and emotionally devastating."

Read Roma Torre’s full review at New York Stage Review

Michael Sommers, in a separate notice, calls it compelling, provocative and ultimately touching, and praises a production meticulously finished in every way. Read Michael Sommers’s review

New York Theatre Guide

"Where does horridness end and humanity begin?"

Reviewer: Gillian Russo

Gillian Russo finds Mantello's production taut, overwhelming and deliberately suffocating, with Freeman giving a standout performance in a uniformly strong ensemble.

"Bruce Norris doesn't let anyone off the hook in Downstate, on stage or off."

She would not rush to see it again, but calls it gut-wrenching, difficult and excellent, the kind of play that keeps an audience arguing on the way out.

Read Gillian Russo’s full review at New York Theatre Guide

K. Todd Freeman, Al’Jaleel McGhee and Thomas Sadoski in Downstate. Photo by Emilio Madrid

Exeunt NYC

Reviewer: Lane Williamson

Lane Williamson, who saw the Playwrights Horizons production, feels some of its electricity has gone, with the focus now on Andy and Fred and Freeman's Dee pushed into second place.

"All in all, Downstate remains a play worth seeing (there isn’t another one like it) and Mantello’s production is finely calibrated."

He still calls Guinan miraculous and Sadoski crackling, and thinks newcomers to the play will be zapped by its intensity.

Read Lane Williamson’s full review at Exeunt NYC

New York Theater

Reviewer: Jonathan Mandell

Jonathan Mandell credits Sadoski's casting with fixing what he saw as the play's biggest problem, and calls McGhee's Broadway debut dazzlingly hyperactive.

"If the Off-Broadway production was superbly acted and directed, the Broadway version is even better."

He remains unconvinced by Norris's argument, which he finds tendentious, but has no quarrel with his skill as a dramatist.

Read Jonathan Mandell’s full review at New York Theater

Production photographs by Emilio Madrid.

For more new work this month, see our roundups for The Steel Man at 59E59 Theaters and the ripple, the wave that carried me home at Playwrights Horizons.

Downstate is playing at the Booth Theatre, 222 West 45th Street, through January 10, 2027.