The reviews are in for The Steel Man, Cary Gitter’s play for Penguin Rep Theatre, now in Theater B at 59E59 Theaters under the direction of Joe Brancato. It is Pittsburgh in 1983, the mills have closed, and Leo, a widowed Hungarian steelworker who survived Auschwitz, has found the man who betrayed his family and bought a gun, just as his son Jake is trying to tell him he is leaving for New York. The critics are warmest about the acting, Sam Guncler’s Leo above all, with Leighton Samuels and Amanda Kristin Nichols close behind. Where they part company is the script: two reviewers are gripped from start to finish, while three think it pulls its punches.
The verdict: five reviews in, and none of the outlets puts a score on it. Talkin’ Broadway and Off Off Online are the most enthusiastic, calling the play forceful, real and suspenseful to the end. Stage and Cinema, Times Square Chronicles and Theater Pizzazz all admire the production but find that the script pulls its punches, settling for restraint where a showdown seems to be coming, or reaching an ending that one of them thinks needs more work. On the company there is no argument: Sam Guncler’s Leo draws the strongest praise, and the 1983 living room designed by Christopher and Justin Swader earns praise from three of them.
What are critics saying about The Steel Man?
Talkin’ Broadway
Reviewer: Moshe A. Bloxenheim
Moshe A. Bloxenheim is the most impressed of the five, calling the play forceful and the production downright visceral. He credits Brancato with building a real pressure cooker between father and son while still finding unexpected laughs.
"Even at its most extreme, The Steel Man is all too real, and its current staging makes for an unforgettable night at the theatre."
He calls all three performances incisive, and says Guncler makes Leo understandable without softening him.
Off Off Online
Reviewer: Rachel S. Kovacs
Rachel S. Kovacs reads the play as a study of trauma handed down from one generation to the next, and of the several men Leo is at once: the actor he never became, the victim and the avenger. She finds Samuels convincing as a dutiful son who resents the duty.
"…the potential for volcanic-level eruptions and suspense throughout are riveting, and a surprise ending brings some level of closure."

Stage and Cinema
"The Sins of the Father"
Reviewer: Paola Bellu
Paola Bellu has warm words for the whole team, from Guncler’s balance of toughness and hidden vulnerability to costumes that mark out each generation. Her reservation is the story, which she thinks promises more fireworks than it delivers and settles for restraint.
"Nevertheless, it is a worthwhile production, and it reminds us of the long shadow cast by unnecessary wars"
Times Square Chronicles
"When the Sins of the Father Become the Burden of the Son"
Reviewer: Suzanna Bowling
Suzanna Bowling is the most skeptical. She finds it hard to invest in Leo, whose suffering explains his cruelty but, in her view, does not excuse it, and she thinks the play raises big questions about justice and revenge without pursuing them.
"The Steel Man contains compelling performances, an inventive production design, and the foundation of a far more penetrating drama."
She praises Brancato’s conviction but would send Gitter back to the script, and to its ending in particular.
Read Suzanna Bowling’s full review at Times Square Chronicles

Theater Pizzazz
"Two Generations Moving On From Trauma"
Reviewer: Alix Cohen
Alix Cohen places the play among Gitter’s works on Jewish themes and calls Guncler’s proud, barely contained survivor a deft portrayal. She would have liked a bigger glimpse of Leo’s fury, and a little more inner struggle from Jake.
"The story is realistic and sympathetic, yet dramatization just misses."

Production photographs by Carol Rosegg.
For more on the production, see our first look at The Steel Man at 59E59 Theaters, and for another new play this month, see our roundup for the ripple, the wave that carried me home at Playwrights Horizons.
The Steel Man is playing in Theater B at 59E59 Theaters, 59 East 59th Street, through December 13.








