Review Roundup: THE GOOD THIEF at the Irish Repertory Theatre

Christopher Fitzgerald in The Good Thief at Irish Repertory Theatre. Photo by Carol Rosegg The reviews are in for The Good Thief, Conor McPherson’s 1994 monologue, which opened at the Irish Repertory Theatre on November 17 with Christopher Fitzgerald as its nameless Irish enforcer. Justin Waldman, artistic director of Two River Theater, which co-produces, directs the 70-minute solo play in the company’s downstairs W. Scott McLucas Studio. Most of the critics agree that an actor best known for sympathetic comic roles turns a violent, unrepentant narrator into an irresistible storyteller, though one finds the evening too gentle for the material.

The verdict: seven outlets have reviewed it so far, and two put a score on it: four out of five from New York Stage Review and 99 percent, 4.95 out of 5, from The Front Row Center. Nearly every critic hands the evening to Christopher Fitzgerald, and most of the reservations are small ones, TheaterMania’s objection to the breaks between chapters and a question about Irish stereotypes. The one real dissent comes from Off Off Online, which finds the production too gentle to reach the play’s darker side. The New York Times, reviewing it alongside another solo play, says both productions feature terrific performers.

What are critics saying about The Good Thief?

TheaterMania

"Christopher Fitzgerald Delights the Audience in The Good Thief"

Reviewer: Francisco Mendoza

Francisco Mendoza was gripped as much by the performance as by the plot, spending the evening searching Fitzgerald’s face and voice for any sign that the character regrets what he has done.

"Fitzgerald doesn’t try to win you over—he just does."

He wondered briefly whether the play leans on Irish stereotypes, and his one real complaint is the music and lighting breaks between chapters, which stop the show for no reason.

Read Francisco Mendoza’s full review at TheaterMania

Christopher Fitzgerald in The Good Thief at Irish Repertory Theatre. Photo by Carol Rosegg

New York Stage Review

"Boastful Self-Incriminating Hero(?) Is More Than Good"

Reviewer: David Finkle · 4 out of 5

David Finkle is fascinated by how ingratiating this criminal manages to be, so that the audience keeps forgetting it is listening to a confession.

"…seeing him meeting the challenge so comfortably, so assuredly, so effortlessly, so winningly."

He sees the evening as overdue recognition for a reliable New York actor, finally given a solo vehicle, and credits the staging with never letting the monologue go static.

Read David Finkle’s full review at New York Stage Review

The Front Row Center

Reviewer: David Walters · 4.95 out of 5

David Walters gave up on his notebook five minutes in, because everything was worth noting and he did not want to miss any of it.

"A firecracker of a play. I can’t recommend it enough."

He praises Fitzgerald for talking with the audience rather than at it, and the plain staging, with Wilson Chin’s set evoking both a pub and a dungeon, for giving the story room.

Read David Walters’s full review at The Front Row Center

Christopher Fitzgerald in The Good Thief at Irish Repertory Theatre. Photo by Carol Rosegg

Talkin’ Broadway

Reviewer: Marc Miller

Marc Miller enjoys watching a performer who usually plays nice guys go the other way, in a play whose language, he warns, gets very filthy.

"He's unmiked, his accent is flawless, and given the small stage, he moves around a lot."

The design stays deliberately in the background, he notes, apart from Drew Levy’s rain soundscape, leaving the evening to Fitzgerald’s expressive, characterful delivery.

Read Marc Miller’s full review at Talkin’ Broadway

Theater Pizzazz

"A Tour de Force!"

Reviewer: Alix Cohen

Alix Cohen admires the way McPherson threads tenderness and lyrical description through a confession of cold-blooded violence, and finds the result impossible to look away from.

"This should forever dispel the assumption he excels only in that genre."

She means musical theater, and she credits Fitzgerald with a performance so natural that the memories seem to surface in the moment. She also praises Justin Waldman’s pacing and singles out Wilson Chin’s pub set and Jen Leno’s lighting.

Read Alix Cohen’s full review at Theater Pizzazz

Off Off Online

Reviewer: Colin Macdonald

Colin Macdonald is the most reserved of the critics so far. He enjoys Fitzgerald’s clear, affable storytelling, but feels the tone is kept so light that the narrator’s violence never chills.

"…is a lightly engaging 70 minutes but is unable to tap into the more sinister resonances of the piece."

He also finds the crime plot familiar and increasingly far-fetched, and says the mother and daughter the narrator flees with never come into focus as characters.

Read Colin Macdonald’s full review at Off Off Online

Also reviewed by: The New York Times (Tim Teeman, "2 Solo Plays Wrestle With the Power of Monologues"), in a joint review with The Exhibitionist.

Production photographs by Carol Rosegg.

For more on the production, see our first look at Christopher Fitzgerald in The Good Thief.

The Good Thief is playing at the Irish Repertory Theatre, 132 West 22nd Street, through December 20.