The reviews are in for The King’s Critique, the new musical comedy by Eric Holmes and Nat Zegree, which opened on November 12 in the Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre at the Pershing Square Signature Center under the direction of Catie Davis. Its kingdom is a mock-Renaissance one where a theater-mad king has banned women from the stage, and its playwright heroine Josephine sets out to change his mind. The critics split sharply over the book, which some find overstuffed and others happily silly, but they agree on Taylor Iman Jones’s voice and on Emily Rebholz’s storybook costumes.
The verdict: five reviews in, and only two of the outlets put a score on it: The Front Row Center gives it 87 percent and Culture Sauce two stars out of five. The Front Row Center and New York Theatre Guide enjoy the silliness, while TheaterMania, Culture Sauce and Talkin’ Broadway find a long evening of jokes that rarely land. Even the doubters praise the company, Taylor Iman Jones above all, and three of the five complain about the sound.
What are critics saying about The King’s Critique?
TheaterMania
"A Critical Queen Reviews The King’s Critique"
Reviewer: Zachary Stewart
Zachary Stewart finds the show funny only in patches and far too long, a satire of the people who decide what gets staged that keeps missing its target. He calls the score pleasant but forgettable and thinks only Justin Collette has the comic technique the material needs.
"…the writers never strike comedic gold, suffering from a deadly combination of unsharpened tools and poor aim."
He also faults the decision to stage it in traverse, which leaves half the audience watching the actors’ backs and the sound unbalanced, and saves his praise for Rebholz’s costumes.
Culture Sauce
"‘The King’s Critique’ is an unruly royal pain of a musical"
Reviewer: Thom Geier · 2 out of 5
Thom Geier sees a show made by and for devoted theater fans that badly needed someone to cut it down, and blames a bloated book that stretches past two and a half hours. He thinks the second act is tighter and the songs stronger.
"There’s a good deal of talent wasted on this unruly royal mess of a show."
He singles out Jones’s singing and a spiky pop-parody number for Gabi Carrubba, but much of the humor, he writes, would have seemed dated a century ago.

The Front Row Center
Reviewer: Sarah Downs · 4.35 out of 5
Sarah Downs is the warmest of the five: she has a lot of fun, and Jones’s voice and storytelling are her highlight of the night. She also admires Collette’s king, Carrubba’s Isabella and the costumes.
"Nevertheless, the musical is loads of fun, with a cast that gives 110% throughout."
Her reservations are the vocal writing, which sits in an awkward key for the cast, a muddy sound balance, too many storylines and a plot that borrows from The Producers.
Talkin’ Broadway
Reviewer: James Wilson
James Wilson places the show in the line of Something Rotten! and Spamalot and credits a fiercely talented, hardworking cast, but finds that most of the jokes miss and that the louder, faster direction does not make it funnier.
"…in its dogged determination to wring every last laugh, there is an enervating sense of been there, done that."
He found the first act painfully overamplified, though he calls the pop-flavored songs generic but appealing.

New York Theatre Guide
"‘The King’s Critique’ Off-Broadway review — a silly royal romp"
Reviewer: Austin Fimmano
Austin Fimmano enjoys the nonstop silliness, the big ensemble numbers and Donna Lynne Champlin’s sardonic Cora, while admitting that not every joke is equally good.
"…a royal romp brimming with energetic songs and ridiculous jokes, but the mixed messaging at its core…"
For him the plot gets too complicated to follow, and the show has little new to say about the sexism at its center.
Production photographs by Russ Rowland.
For more on the production, see our production photos from The King’s Critique and our opening night photos, and for this week’s big Broadway opening, see our roundup for Downstate at the Booth Theatre.
The King’s Critique is playing at the Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre at the Pershing Square Signature Center, 480 West 42nd Street, through December 20.








