The reviews are in for The Fantasticks, which opened at the Hayes Theater on November 16, giving the world’s longest-running musical its first Broadway production 66 years after it premiered on Sullivan Street. Second Stage presents the version Tom Jones revised before his death in 2023, in which Matt falls for the boy next door, Lewis, and the scheming fathers become scheming mothers, with Christopher Gattelli directing and choreographing. The critics largely agree the switch costs the show nothing: most find it slots in with barely a ripple, and the warmest notices call it a gentle, uncynical delight. The praise goes above all to Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer as the mothers, with Kevin Del Aguila and David Patrick Kelly close behind as the two old actors, while the doubts gather around the second act, the bigger Broadway scale and a revision some feel did not go far enough.
The verdict: fourteen outlets have reviewed it so far, fifteen critics in all, and only four of the outlets put a score on it: four out of five from Time Out New York, Culture Sauce and 1 Minute Critic, and a split at New York Stage Review, where one critic gives four and the other three. The unrated notices lean warm, from TheaterMania’s “sweet little gem” to the Guardian and Stage and Cinema, and almost everyone agrees the boy-meets-boy rewrite sits lightly on the show. The reservations are about the old musical itself, a second act that still drags for Deadline and Culture Sauce, and the bigger Broadway scale, which bothers New York Theater and one of the New York Stage Review critics. On the acting there is no argument: Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer are praised everywhere, and Maxim Chlumecky is singled out by several.
What are critics saying about The Fantasticks?
The New York Times
"A Gender Swap for a Still-Tender Story"
Reviewer: Elisabeth Vincentelli
Elisabeth Vincentelli sets the revival beside the fashion for regendering classic musicals, and points out that Broadway is about the least likely place for two boys in love to raise an eyebrow.
"A gay couple onstage is not going to make anyone in a New York City audience clutch his pearls."
Inside the show nobody blinks either, she notes, and her verdict is that the old musical’s quaint nostalgia comes through the change intact.
Read Elisabeth Vincentelli’s full review in The New York Times
Vulture
"The Curious Paradox of the Rethought Fantasticks"
Reviewer: Sara Holdren
Sara Holdren calls it a charming revival and finds the show’s soft, fairy-tale heart needs almost no adjusting to take two boys, handing much of the credit to Miles and Kritzer, with Kelly and Del Aguila not far behind.
"…what’s shaky about the show is apt to stay shaky, while what’s beautiful about it will always be beautiful."
She closes by wondering aloud whether a love story that fits so neatly into the old shape is as far as the idea can go.
The Guardian
"gay reimagining of musical is a heartwarming delight"
Reviewer: Richard Lawson
Richard Lawson sends anyone missing Heartstopper straight to the Hayes, praising the leads’ voices, the mothers’ mix of ham and heart, the two old vaudevillians and the design, and singling out the final tableau.
"…a warm invitation to the uninitiated to forgive its slight corniness and succumb to its gentle charms."
He allows that the line between endearing and twee is a fine one that some will feel the show crosses, but says longtime fans should be carried away.

Deadline
"A Welcome Broadway Debut Seven Decades In The Making"
Reviewer: Greg Evans
Greg Evans finds the second act as contrived and draggy as ever, but credits Gattelli and a game cast with nearly hiding the weak spots, and says Chlumecky steals just about every scene he is in.
"They, and everything else in this production, work together to bring a theatrical warhorse galloping into 21st Century Broadway"
The gender switch, he adds, is supported with remarkable ease.
TheaterMania
"The Fantasticks Is a Gay Old Time on Broadway—but Not Gay Enough"
Reviewer: David Gordon
David Gordon calls Chlumecky a genuine star and the mothers a showstopping double act, and loves the duets, the tap solo for Ahmad Simmons and the clear, unforced sound.
"This production for Second Stage at the Helen Hayes Theater is loving and uncynical, a sweet little gem"
His reservation is the rewrite: Lewis gets a new name and pronouns without much thought for how a young gay man might act, which leaves Levy short-changed. He still calls the production a rarefied treasure.
TheWrap
"The Vintage Musical Successfully Moves Uptown Under a Lavender Moon"
Reviewer: Robert Hofler
Robert Hofler teases that parents so keen to promote a same-sex romance make the show feel set on another planet, and finds Zane Phillips’s muscle-bound El Gallo the gayest thing in it.
"whenever David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila are on stage, it is an utter delight."
He also praises the singing and a sound design that lets the voices breathe instead of blasting them.

Time Out New York
"makes new magick"
Reviewer: Adam Feldman · 4 out of 5
Adam Feldman once wrote that the show belonged in the history books, and here he cheerfully eats those words, finding a production rooted in the show’s past that blooms in the present.
"The queering of Cats: The Jellicle Ball was radically loud; this one is radically soft."
He praises Chlumecky and Levy, the mothers and the hammy old actors, and the score’s full-throated singing, though he feels Phillips lacks the gravitas for El Gallo’s worldly-wise passages.
New York Stage Review
"Fresh but Still Familiar"
Reviewer: Melissa Rose Bernardo · 4 out of 5
Melissa Rose Bernardo finds a moony production that matches the Fantasticks most people carry in their heads, from Jen Schriever’s sunset lighting to Sam Davis’s new orchestrations.
"Ideologically, it’s a big change; dramaturgically, it’s surprisingly small."
She says the mothers nearly walk off with the show, and that a newcomer would never guess the lovers had once been a boy and a girl.
Read Melissa Rose Bernardo’s full review at New York Stage Review
New York Stage Review
"Somehow Short of Fantastic(k)"
Reviewer: David Finkle · 3 out of 5
David Finkle, a self-declared partisan of the original, regrets seeing the piano and harp wheeled away in favor of something grander, though he praises the score and the supporting players.
"The drawback here—it’s not meager—is that the boys’ love affair comes across as tepid."
His word for the revision as a whole is “overdone.”
Culture Sauce
"‘The Fantasticks’ finds new queer love in an old trunk of musical tricks"
Reviewer: Thom Geier · 4 out of 5
Thom Geier calls the revival thoroughly charming, admires Kritzer and Miles as singers and comedians, and credits Davis’s orchestrations with a lush sound that never swamps the story.
"Still, you’d have to be a hard-hearted cynic yourself to resist the charms of The Fantasticks."
He finds the darker second act unnecessary, some of its lyrics stilted and the abduction scene a letdown.

1 Minute Critic
"Boy meets boy as ‘The Fantasticks’ finally bows on Broadway"
Reviewer: Billy McEntee · 4 out of 5
Billy McEntee finds Gattelli’s staging joyous, though the bigger stage sometimes reminds him why the show thrived in smaller rooms, and he says Phillips simply beguiles.
"The magic is how little needs changing: the show captures the burning romance of adolescence, which knows no bounds."
His conclusion is that the long-delayed Broadway bow was worth the wait.
New York Theatre Guide
"long-running musical makes a heartstopping Broadway debut"
Reviewer: Joe Dziemianowicz
Joe Dziemianowicz finds the early stretch too precious, the staged kidnapping cringe-making and “Much More” an awkward fit for Lewis, but calls Chlumecky just plain wonderful and Kritzer a comic ace.
"Six decades since the show burst on the scene, that feels like progress worth singing about."
What stays with him is that the mothers argue about gardening while their sons’ romance is a total non-issue.
Read Joe Dziemianowicz’s full review at New York Theatre Guide
New York Theater
Reviewer: Jonathan Mandell
Jonathan Mandell thinks the bigger house, band and set intrude on this chamber musical far more than the change of gender does.
"This enlargement feels far more intrusive than the change to two boys"
He is glad to see Nathan Levy and the two mothers given their chance, but finds that Lewis waiting to be rescued by Matt now carries stereotypes of its own.

Stage and Cinema
Reviewer: Rob Lester
Rob Lester finds the Hayes, Broadway’s smallest house, a cozy home, and credits Gattelli and Sherwood with resisting the urge to supersize the show.
"Timeless and tender, sentimental and sassy, high-spirited and highly recommended."
He notes that leaving Lewis at home in the second act gives the old lessons about innocence and experience a fresh resonance.
Theater Pizzazz
"A Cardboard Moon with Diamond Stars"
Reviewer: Alex Eichholz
Alex Eichholz calls the revival a success at keeping the original’s delicacy, praising the lovers’ chemistry and the mothers’ comic timing, and naming “Plant a Radish” the emotional crux of the evening.
"Like the flowers that gradually emerge throughout the evening, this revival finds new life in familiar soil."
His one reservation is Phillips, whose voice captivates though his acting occasionally lacks conviction.
Production photographs by Joan Marcus.
For more on the production, see our first look at The Fantasticks in production photos and our eight things you might not know about the show, and for the other big Broadway opening of the week, see our roundup for Downstate at the Booth Theatre.
The Fantasticks is playing at the Hayes Theater, 240 West 44th Street, through February 7, 2027.








