Alex Brightman and Sara Chase set January 17 exit from Schmigadoon! on Broadway

Alex Brightman and Sara Chase, the original Broadway leads of Schmigadoon! Alex Brightman and Sara Chase, who created the roles of Josh Skinner and Melissa Gamble in Schmigadoon! on Broadway, will play their final performances at the Nederlander Theatre on Sunday, January 17, 2027, and the actors who succeed them have yet to be named.

The production announced the departures in a post on its Instagram account on November 13, and replacement casting will follow at a later date. The timing leaves eleven weeks between their exit and the musical's currently scheduled final performance on April 4, 2027, so the winner of the 2026 Tony Award for Best Musical will play the last stretch of its Broadway run with new leads at its center.

Both performers belong to the original Broadway company and have been in place since before the April 20, 2026 opening night. As Josh and Melissa, the New York couple whose relationship is already fraying when they wander into a town that lives as if every day were a Golden Age musical, they carry most of the evening, and the role brought Chase a Tony nomination. Her earlier Broadway credits include Myrtle Wilson in The Great Gatsby and Woman 1 in First Date. Brightman is a two-time Tony nominee, for School of Rock and Beetlejuice, and played Sir Lancelot in the 2023 revival of Spamalot before joining the show.

The announcement is the latest in a run of changes at the top of the company. Jennifer Simard plays her last performance as Mildred Layton on Sunday, November 29, having extended her stay, and Michelle Visage takes over the role from December 4 in a limited engagement that ends on January 31, 2027, two weeks after Brightman and Chase take their final bows.

Cinco Paul wrote the book, music and lyrics, adapting the Apple TV+ series he co-created, and Christopher Gattelli directs and choreographs. Lorne Michaels leads the producing team. The production has also announced a national tour, due to launch in September 2027.

Tickets for Schmigadoon! at the Nederlander Theatre are available here.