First look: Now You See Me Live’s Horsemen take the stage at the Al Hirschfeld

Matthew Pomeroy, Darcy Oake, Eden Choi, Gabriella Lester and James More in Now You See Me Live on Broadway. Photo by Jeremy Daniel The first production photos from Now You See Me Live on Broadway show the Horsemen lined up under a ceiling of blue stage lights, cards frozen in mid-air, and Darcy Oake locked into a water-filled tank while a stage clock counts the seconds. The magic show is in performances at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre through January 3, 2027.

Jeremy Daniel photographed the Broadway company, and the frames follow the shape of the evening: the Horsemen together, then each act alone in a pool of light. The four are escapologist Gabriella Lester from South Africa, illusionist James More from England, illusionist Darcy Oake from Canada and mentalist Matthew Pomeroy, also from England. Most of the color in these pictures is Hugo Mercier-Bosseny’s lighting design: hard blue beams, banks of spotlights and, in the curtain-call shot, a cascade of sparks.

The fifth face in the group shots is Eden Choi, the Korean magician who reached the semi-finals of Britain’s Got Talent in 2025. Choi’s solo frames are all cards: fanned, thrown and caught. Choi is a special guest through November 29 only. From December 1 until the run ends, the guest spot passes to Korean magician Yollin Lee, named The Magic Circle’s Stage Magician of the Year in Manipulation in 2024.

Performances began on November 11 for a limited engagement of eight weeks. The show grows out of Lionsgate’s Now You See Me films, in which the Four Horsemen pull off heists by illusion, and it is presented by Tim Lawson and Simon Painter, the producers behind The Illusionists, in collaboration with Lionsgate. New York follows a year of sold-out engagements in Australia, Singapore and London’s West End, where it played the London Coliseum, and a company is currently in residence at the MGM Grand on the Las Vegas Strip.

Painter is the show’s creator and creative producer, with Adam Trent as co-creator, Ash Jacks McCready as creative director and staging director, Kirsty White as creative director, Enzo Wenye as illusion director and Evan Duffy as composer. Jenefer Brown, Lionsgate’s President of Global Products & Experiences, is creative consultant.

Three $42 routes run every day. The Lucky Seat digital lottery draws at 11am ET, with winners able to buy up to two tickets. The TodayTix digital rush opens at 9am ET on the day of each performance, two tickets per person. The Al Hirschfeld box office sells in-person rush on the day, two per patron. The $42 includes all fees, and those seats can be anywhere in the house, partial view included. Earlier on this site: the special guest casting and the box office opening.

The Al Hirschfeld Theatre is at 302 West 45th Street. Tickets are on sale through the production’s own site, broadway.nowyouseemelive.com.

Production photos from Now You See Me Live on Broadway