The reviews are in for Blue Man Group: A New Holiday Surprise, which opened at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre on November 17. It is the troupe’s first holiday show and its Broadway debut, arriving less than two years after the original production closed at the Astor Place Theatre after a 34-year run. Matt Ramsey directs a rotating company of Blue Men, and the critics broadly agree that the signature routines have made the trip intact. Where they part company is on whether that is enough: most of the notices so far call the holiday “surprise” a familiar evening in new wrapping, while Stage and Cinema is simply glad to have the Blue Men home for Christmas.
The verdict: six outlets have reviewed it so far, and only one puts a score on it: three out of five from 1 Minute Critic. Beyond that the notices split clearly. Vulture, TheaterMania, New York Theater and 1 Minute Critic all say the “new holiday surprise” is the old Astor Place show with carols added, and TheaterMania is the most severe. New York Theatre Guide worries that the act loses its intimacy in a big Broadway house, while Stage and Cinema is the one notice without reservations. What nobody disputes is the music: whenever the Blue Men turn to the drums and the PVC pipes, the show works.
What are critics saying about Blue Man Group: A New Holiday Surprise?
Vulture
"What’s Red and Green and Blue All Over?"
Reviewer: Jackson McHenry
Jackson McHenry spent days afterward looking for the surprise in the title and did not find one: the Blue Men drum, splash paint, play the PVC pipes and pull people out of the audience, as they always have.
"In the show, which has touched down on Broadway to beckon seasonal tourists, nothing especially unexpected takes place."
He reckons audience participation fills a large share of the 80 minutes, so your enjoyment depends on how willing you are to meet a Blue Man’s eye, and he finds the troupe’s old send-up of consumerism gentler than ever.

TheaterMania
"Blue Man Group’s Broadway Christmas Show Is a Lump of Coal"
Reviewer: Dan Rubins
Dan Rubins is the coolest of the critics. He runs through the familiar business, now in red and green, and finds nothing original, festive or surprising in it.
"He is then revealed to be wearing a wreath over his crotch. This, I fear, is the actual New Holiday Surprise."
He also struggled to follow the long stretches in the aisles, which reach most of the house only as a blurry camera feed projected over the fireplace.
1 Minute Critic
"Blue Man Group crams its greatest hits into an overstuffed Broadway stocking"
Reviewer: Bobby McGuire · 3 out of 5
Bobby McGuire finds every signature bit present and correct, from the paint drums to the marshmallow catch, with the carols squeezed in around them.
"If you’ve ever spent an evening with Blue Man Group, this is a regift in shinier paper…"
He admires Scott Adam Davis’s mid-century set, and concedes that the small children in his audience were having the time of their lives.

New York Theatre Guide
"deck the halls with paint and drumming"
Reviewer: Caroline Cao
Caroline Cao, new to Blue Man Group, asks whether a wordless downtown act can fill a 1,500-seat house, and finds the audience-participation sequences hard going from a distance, especially for the mezzanine.
"Because whenever they’re slapping colors onto blank canvases, the Blue Men are in their element."
The percussion numbers win her over completely, but the satirical TV commercials and much of the prerecorded sound work against the show.
New York Theater
Reviewer: Jonathan Mandell
Jonathan Mandell finds nothing here that a visitor to Astor Place would not recognize, and thinks the 1950s-advertising satire, daring in the 1980s, now just feels old.
"What may be most surprising about this holiday surprise is how unsurprising it is"
He calls the audience interaction extensive and aggressive and the snowy set gorgeous but underused. The best of the holiday material, for him, is a straightforward mini-concert of carols on the PVC pipes.

Stage and Cinema
Reviewer: Paulanne Simmons
Paulanne Simmons is the warmest of the six. She enjoys the gently subversive picture of three wide-eyed outsiders let loose in a 1950s magazine home at Christmas.
"…much of the show’s appeal comes from the Blue Men’s ability to communicate without speaking."
She warns that it is very loud for the youngest children, but she ends on the confetti-and-streamers finale and hopes this will not be the group’s last holiday show.
Production photographs by Michaelah Reynolds.
For more on the production, see our first photos and video from the Lunt-Fontanne.
Blue Man Group: A New Holiday Surprise is playing at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, 205 West 46th Street, through January 3, 2027.








