The reviews are in for Elektra, Daniel Fish’s new staging of Sophocles in Anne Carson’s translation, which opened at Theatre for a New Audience’s Polonsky Shakespeare Center in Brooklyn on November 20. It is not the version Fish brought to London’s West End with Brie Larson and Stockard Channing: he has rebuilt it around a long runway, with the audience on three sides and an a cappella chorus of six singing Ted Hearne’s score. On one point the critics agree almost to a person: Tina Benko’s Elektra and Hearne’s chorus are the reasons to go. Where they part company is over Fish’s topical additions, a replica of Renée Good’s SUV parked beside the stage and a passage about Christa Pike’s botched execution, which most of them find more distracting than illuminating.
The verdict: six reviews so far, three of them scored: four out of five from New York Stage Review, three from Culture Sauce and two from Theater Life. TheaterMania is the most enthusiastic of the rest, calling the evening electric on the strength of the choral writing. Praise for Tina Benko is close to unanimous, and Sally Wingert’s Clytemnestra and Rebecca Naomi Jones’s Chrysothemis get warm mentions too. The split is over Daniel Fish’s current-events inserts: Exeunt NYC, Culture Sauce and This Week in New York all wish he had trusted the play, and Theater Life’s Samuel L. Leiter thinks the concept smothers it. The New York Times had not reviewed it at the time of writing.
What are critics saying about Elektra?
TheaterMania
"Daniel Fish’s Elektra Is Electric, Thanks to Ted Hearne’s Choral Score"
Reviewer: Dan Rubins
Dan Rubins hears the production’s engine in the chorus: six treble voices in tight, crunchy harmony answering Elektra’s laments, which he finds mesmerizing.
"Elektra draws its centrifugal power from the harmony at its core…"
He admires the bitterness of Benko’s performance, the fight between Elektra and Wingert’s pugnacious Clytemnestra, and Carson’s taut, accessible text. Not every image makes sense to him, and he finds the topical material vaguer than the play itself, but the choices that land carry the night.
New York Stage Review
"Grade-A Director Daniel Fish Has His Creative Way With Sophokles"
Reviewer: David Finkle · 4 out of 5
David Finkle, an admitted fan, files Fish among the directors who impose a personal take rather than excavate a text, and he enjoys where that takes this one.
"…the acting ensemble is uniformly dynamic. This, however, is Benko’s showcase."
He walks through the runway staging, the six-woman chorus and the battered car in the pit with evident pleasure, though he openly wonders what the late passage about Christa Pike is doing there, and whether all that stage blood is becoming a Fish signature.

Culture Sauce
"Daniel Fish’s ‘Elektra’ crackles when it’s not straining to be woke"
Reviewer: Thom Geier · 3 out of 5
Thom Geier calls the production often gorgeous and the cast wonderful, and singles out the six singers for their solos and their blend.
"Benko is sensational throughout, and her scenes with Wingert crackle like two oppositely charged particles…"
His objection is to the 2026 references layered on top, from the replica car to Clytemnestra draped in a flag, which he finds jarringly literal and muddled. He wishes Fish had trusted Carson’s text over his own commentary.
Theater Life
Reviewer: Samuel L. Leiter · 2 out of 5
Samuel L. Leiter is the toughest critic so far. He puts Fish alongside Ivo van Hove and Jamie Lloyd as directors who divide the critics, and argues that here the concept overwhelms the play instead of opening it up.
"…his theatrical hokum amounts to ho-hum theatricality."
He finds the sung choral lines lovely to hear but hard to follow, and says the gimmicks, from the Coke can to the buckets of blood, keep the actors from connecting with their characters.

Exeunt NYC
"Tina Benko’s performance as Elektra carries the day even when Daniel Fish’s embellishments distract."
Reviewer: Loren Noveck
Loren Noveck praises the clarity with which the company speaks Carson’s verse, Benko’s real anguish and the haunting music of the chorus, and finds Elektra’s stuck, impotent rage strikingly current on its own terms.
"These interventions feel like pure provocation: poking up through the surface of the play to snag our attention…"
That is why the topical inserts bother her. She is not sure what message each one is meant to send, and argues that everything they point at is already in the words and the performances.
This Week in New York
"Violence Breeds Violence: Daniel Fish’s Elektra in Brooklyn"
Reviewer: Mark Rifkin
Mark Rifkin saw Fish’s London version too, and compares the two in detail. He likes the cast: Benko fierce, Wingert a worthy adversary and Jones radiant.
"…despite the myriad differences, it is still both elektrifying and mystifying."
He thinks the car, the diet Coke and the late monologue drain the show’s energy, and warns that the lighting can glare and that seats at the sides miss some of the action.

Production photographs by Maria Baranova.
For more on the production, see our casting story on Tina Benko and Rebecca Naomi Jones in Elektra.
Elektra is playing at Theatre for a New Audience’s Polonsky Shakespeare Center, 262 Ashland Place, Brooklyn, through December 13.








