Review Roundup: SLAM FRANK at the Orpheum Theatre

Alex Lewis, Jaz Zepatos, Olivia Bernábe, Rocky Paterra and Austen Horne in Slam Frank at the Orpheum Theatre. Photo by Shawn Salley Photography

The reviews are in for Slam Frank, Andrew Fox and Joel Sinensky’s satirical hip-hop musical in which a well-meaning theater company recasts Anne Frank as Anita Franco, a queer Latina rapper, which opened at the Orpheum Theatre on October 4. Directed by Sam LaFrage, it sets out to offend everyone, and the critics are as divided as you would expect. 1 Minute Critic and The Front Row Center are thrilled by its nerve, Culture Sauce finds it overlong and in places plain distasteful, and Vulture was more bored than shocked. What nearly all of them agree on is that Fox’s score is sharp and that Olivia Bernábe is terrific as Anita.

The verdict: thirteen reviews so far, and three carry a score: 1 Minute Critic gives the show 4 out of 5, New York Stage Review 3 and Culture Sauce 2, an average of 3.0 among the outlets that rate. The rest publish no score. Most of the critics agree that Andrew Fox writes clever, catchy pastiche and that the cast, led by Olivia Bernábe, is excellent; where they part company is over whether the satire earns its provocations, which The Front Row Center, 1 Minute Critic, The A.V. Club, David Cote, Stage and Cinema and The Unforgettable Line believe it does and Vulture, Culture Sauce, New York Theater and Off Off Online doubt.

What are critics saying about Slam Frank?

Vulture

"Deep in an Irony Spiral, Slam Frank Struggles to Show Its Center"

Reviewer: Jackson McHenry

Jackson McHenry finds the show’s targets oddly dated, its jokes about land acknowledgments and identity politics already well worn by stand-up comedians, and its layers of parody so thick that he cannot tell where its creators actually stand.

"I was ready to be shocked and offended, and might even have liked it, I was more often a little bored."

What redeems it for him is Fox’s genuine skill as a songwriter, with an ear for Lin-Manuel Miranda’s flow, and Bernábe’s easy, winning delivery.

Read Jackson McHenry’s full review at Vulture

The A.V. Club

"Slam Frank might be the most subversive show in New York"

Reviewer: Drew Gillis

Drew Gillis admits the opening run of identity-politics gags spins its wheels at times and goes after an easy target, but argues that the show’s real subject is the theater itself.

"…a satire of contemporary theater sharp enough to draw blood if wielded incorrectly."

Once it reaches its final stretch he finds it genuinely daring, calls the closing image as disturbing as anything in Cabaret, and says nothing else he has seen on stage this year has stayed with him as long.

Read Drew Gillis’s full review at The A.V. Club

TheaterMania

"Slam Frank Is Back, and She Doesn’t Care If You Cancel Her"

Reviewer: Hayley Levitt

Hayley Levitt calls Fox’s score one of the better Hamilton knockoffs, with clever lyrics and catchy tunes, and praises a cast in which every performer gets a moment.

"No doubt, Slam Frank is a bucking bronco in a world of pony rides."

She warns that the show grows wilder as it goes and that some will decide it crosses the line into antisemitism, but thinks those who hang on may come away shaken loose.

Read Hayley Levitt’s full review at TheaterMania

New York Stage Review

"The Jewish teen author/Holocaust victim gets an audacious 21st-century musical glow-up"

Reviewer: Melissa Rose Bernardo · 3 out of 5

Melissa Rose Bernardo thinks the show takes aim at too much at once, cramming its 110 minutes with more digs than it can land.

"Slam Frank takes aim at pretty much everyone and everything, and about 50 percent of the shots hit their targets."

She singles out Austen Horne’s slam poem as Edith as a moment of real brilliance, and predicts that Margot’s big number will be the evening’s most divisive scene.

Read Melissa Rose Bernardo’s full review at New York Stage Review

Amelia Louise Barr and the cast of Slam Frank at the Orpheum Theatre. Photo by Shawn Salley Photography

1 Minute Critic

"the diary decolonized"

Reviewer: Matthew Wexler · 4 out of 5

Matthew Wexler admits that the pace means some bits fly past before they land, and that Fox’s borrowings from other musicals start to feel derivative.

"its willingness to offend everyone equally makes it the most daring ticket Off-Broadway this fall."

For him the laughter stops at the right moment, when the show turns to history repeating itself, and that is where it lands its hardest punch.

Read Matthew Wexler’s full review at 1 Minute Critic

Culture Sauce

"Lampoons wokeness with jackboots and rap verses while testing the limits of taste"

Reviewer: Thom Geier · 2 out of 5

Thom Geier enjoys the verbal dexterity of Fox’s score and the voices of Bernábe and Alex Lewis, and finds some appeal in using an untouchable icon to mock progressive excess.

"It’s brash, deliberately provocative, sometimes hilarious in a silly way, and eventually overstays its welcome."

He finds the nearly two hours too long and too scattershot, and is troubled by a late twist that leaves the show’s Nazi more sympathetic than its one fully Jewish character.

Read Thom Geier’s full review at Culture Sauce

Times Square Chronicles

"Brilliant, Offensive, Confusing—and Impossible to Stop Talking About"

Reviewer: Suzanna Bowling

Suzanna Bowling is torn: she finds it hard to separate the joke from the real child at the heart of the story, and says plainly that parts of it offended her.

"I also think its cast is beyond, beyond, beyond talented, Andrew Fox’s score is fabulous"

She expects the show’s sheer theatrical invention to win it a cult following, which is precisely what troubles her about it.

Read Suzanna Bowling’s full review at Times Square Chronicles

Austen Horne as Edith in Slam Frank at the Orpheum Theatre. Photo by Shawn Salley Photography

New York Theater

Reviewer: Jonathan Mandell

Jonathan Mandell enjoys the early zingers, Andrew Fox’s clever pastiche score and a game, talented cast, but finds the show less entertaining and its purpose murkier as nearly two hours roll by without a break.

"…winds up a muddle and maybe something worse."

His sharpest objection is to the late number built on antisemitic caricature, which he cannot square with the sincere pro-Palestinian ballad that follows, and he ends up suspecting the show has become the very virtue signaling it sets out to mock.

Read Jonathan Mandell’s full review at New York Theater

Off Off Online

Reviewer: Marc Miller

Marc Miller finds the anachronism-stuffed concept exhausting, a nonstop barrage of jokes about competing victimhood, and draws the line at the Palestine number.

"…your sides may be sore from being poked in the ribs so relentlessly."

He has real praise for the company, especially Olivia Bernábe’s Anne and Alex Lewis’s Peter, allows that the book and lyrics land the occasional good line, and notes that the audience around him loved it.

Read Marc Miller’s full review at Off Off Online

Cote Notices

Reviewer: David Cote

David Cote went in braced to be offended and came out delighted, welcoming a deliberately tasteless spoof of virtue-signaling theater after years of cautious, earnest drama, even if some of its targets feel dated.

"…a hair-raising, demented joyride with immensely sharp and resourceful acting and design."

He singles out Olivia Bernábe as a tireless Anne with a superb voice and Amelia Louise Barr’s showstopper as Margot, and ranks it the most effective new musical he has seen since Dead Outlaw.

Read David Cote’s full review at Cote Notices

Stage and Cinema

“An outrageous Afro-Latin hip-hop reinvention of Anne Frank goes gleefully where you can’t believe it dares to go”

Reviewer: Gregory Fletcher

Gregory Fletcher calls it an outrageous Afro-Latin hip-hop retelling of Anne Frank that keeps topping its own absurdity, right up to an ending that piles on three more jaw-droppers.

"The choices aren’t daring simply for absurdity’s sake; many are genuinely provocative…"

He praises Andrew Fox’s affectionate pastiche score and a cast of eight with big voices, singles out Olivia Bernábe’s Anita and Alex Lewis’s Peter, and enjoys watching a progressive audience laugh at its own politics; his one quibble is a costume for Peter that never changes as the character does.

Read Gregory Fletcher’s full review at Stage and Cinema

The Front Row Center

"Slam Frank Is the Gut-Punch You Didn’t Know You Needed… And You’ll Laugh the Whole Way Through"

Reviewer: David Walters

David Walters is the show’s most enthusiastic champion here, calling Bernábe the beating heart of the evening and praising Lewis and Amelia Louise Barr for grounding it amid the chaos.

"this is one of the things that theater is supposed to do."

He argues that its provocation serves something close to hopeful, and urges audiences to go and argue about it on the way home.

Read David Walters’s full review at The Front Row Center

The Unforgettable Line

Reviewer: Cathy Hammer

Cathy Hammer is firmly on the show’s side, reading it as a direct answer to the 2022 tweet that asked whether Anne Frank ever acknowledged her white privilege. She admires the whole company, with Bernábe a quick, eager guide and Austen Horne’s Edith and Rocky Paterra’s anxious Otto both winning her over.

"…this one-of-a-kind entertainment that lightens bitter herb satire with up-to-the-minute parody and a head-bopping score."

She credits director Sam LaFrage and choreographer Esosa Oviasu with making the most of the Orpheum’s narrow stage by spilling the action into the aisles, and her only warning is for anyone who takes offense easily: this is not their evening.

Read Cathy Hammer’s full review at The Unforgettable Line

For more of what the New York critics have been saying, read our roundups for Kramer/Fauci at St. Ann’s Warehouse and Garry Starr: Classic Penguins at Studio Seaview.

Slam Frank runs at the Orpheum Theatre, 126 Second Avenue, through November 30, 2026. The running time is 1 hour 50 minutes, with no intermission. Production photos by Shawn Salley Photography.