Traitorz: The Unauthorized Musical Parody had its official Off-Broadway opening on Friday, November 13, at St. Luke's Theatre, and two guests from outside the company joined the game for the night: Broadway's Casey Likes and RuPaul's Drag Race star Jackie Cox, who played it as Lisa Rinna.
The show is Tim Murray's send-up of the reality competition The Traitors, with the contestants replaced by impersonations of the famous. Dylan Adler hosts as Alan Cumming, and the players checking into the castle include Jennifer Coolidge (Becca Kötte), Liza Minnelli (Daniel Barrett), Patti LuPone (Sean McManus), Britney Spears (Rachel Schur) and Jesus (Jeffrey Omura), with DeShawn Bowens and Cassidy Stoner as standbys. Members of the audience are drafted onstage at every performance and secretly sorted into Faithfuls and Traitors, so no two nights end the same way.
On opening night Likes and Cox sat at the round table as guest contestants, and Michael Bullard also took part in the evening's game. In the audience were Drag Race winner Sasha Velour and Broadway performers Barrett Wilbert Weed, Alex Wyse, Isabelle McCalla and Andrew Chappelle, along with Mark Sonnenblick, Isaac Josephthal and Clyde Voce. Afterward the company and guests moved on to the newly opened Mister Foggs, a short walk along West 46th Street.
If the clip does not load, watch it on Instagram.
Opening night at Traitorz
The first notices are in. The Recs gave the show four stars, calling it "delightfully deranged" and "a killer good time," and Randall David Cook picked out Adler's Cumming as "riotous and charming." For New York Theatre Guide, Austin Fimmano called it "a fun romp through reality TV's latest obsession."
Murray, a comedian whose work has been seen on the Tony Awards, wrote the book and lyrics and co-directs with Alan Kliffer. The score is by Ben Fankhauser, whose credits include Newsies, with music direction, arrangements and orchestrations by Kyle Branzel and choreography by Alex Hartman. Riw Rakkulchon designs the set, Kindall Almond the costumes and wigs, Zack Lobel the lighting and Germán Martínez the sound. Rafaella Rosenberg produces.
We have followed the show since the run was announced, through the completed cast and the first production photos.
Traitorz runs at St. Luke's Theatre, 308 West 46th Street, in a limited engagement through January 31, 2027, with tickets from $39. Book on our Traitorz show page.










