Edinburgh Fringe hit Something To Believe In makes its New York premiere in Long Island City

Key art for Something To Believe In, written and performed by Sarah Alice Shull Sarah Alice Shull’s solo play Something To Believe In, which drew four-star reviews at the 2024 Edinburgh Festival Fringe, gets its New York premiere at the Court Square Theater in Long Island City this winter. Erin Reynolds directs a three-week limited Off-Broadway engagement opening in January 2027.

Shull wrote the piece and plays a version of herself in it: a senior at an all-girls Catholic school in Kentucky in 2012, with graduation in sight. Over the course of a single school day she starts to question the faith she was raised in while coming to terms with her own queerness, and she puts the obvious question to the audience, who stand in as her congregation: can the two live side by side, and should they? Along the way, the 70-minute show also finds room for who gets into heaven and how to build a car that runs on water.

The show arrives with its Fringe notices intact. The Scotsman gave it four stars, writing that it “burns bright as a supernova in its flawless writing, performance and direction,” and ThreeWeeks Edinburgh also awarded four stars.

“It’s gonna crack your heart in two and sew it back together with comedy and love,” said Shull, who added that the show is “here for the girls, the gays, the theys, and people who love stained glass.” Reynolds, a Kentucky-raised director who specializes in new work, said the material is “even more relevant now than when we started working on it three years ago.”

Shull’s New York credits include work at Playwrights Horizons, Joe’s Pub at The Public Theater and The Flea Theater, where she is a member of the Resident Acting Company; she was also part of the fifth cohort of the Public’s BARS program. Reynolds has directed at the Eugene O’Neill Theater Center, the Atlantic Acting School, The Tank and The Flea.

The design team is Stephanie Bahniuk (scenic design) and Hayley Garcia Parnell (lighting design), with Alex Taylor as movement coordinator and Emani Brielle Simpson as stage manager. Rachel Ackerman produces, in association with Jen Beck and Theatre East at Court Square Theater.

Performances run from Thursday, January 7, to Saturday, January 30, 2027, with press performances on January 7 and 8 and opening night on Saturday, January 9, at 7:30 p.m. The regular schedule is Monday through Saturday at 7:30 p.m., plus 3 p.m. matinees on Saturdays and Sundays. There are no performances on Tuesday, January 12, Monday, January 18 (Martin Luther King Jr. Day) or Tuesday, January 26.

The Court Square Theater is at 44-02 23rd Street in Long Island City, between 44th Avenue and 44th Road. Tickets are $35, sold online and in person at the theater from half an hour before each performance; details are on the show’s official website.