Classic Stage Company has added 19 performances of Penelope, the Richard Rodgers Award-winning chamber musical starring Grace McLean, taking a run that was due to end on December 20 through to January 21, 2027.
The engagement at CSC’s Lynn F. Angelson Theater on East 13th Street still begins on December 10, with opening night on Friday, December 11, but very few seats are left for the original December 10–20 dates; CSC says the first on-sale was one of the best-selling days it has ever had. The new block runs January 5–21, 2027.
The musical tells Homer’s The Odyssey from the shore rather than the sea. Twenty years after her husband sailed for Troy, Penelope finally gives her account of the wait, and she wants a drink before she starts. McLean, whose Broadway credits include Suffs and Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812, carries the evening alone, with five musicians around her acting as a Greek chorus: Alex Bechtel on piano, Rachel Massey on violin, Nicole Fassold Harabaru on viola, Justin Yoder on cello and Hiroyuki Matsuura on percussion.
Bechtel wrote the folk-pop score, music and lyrics both, and is the music director. He shares the book with McLean and Eva Steinmetz, who directs. The design team, announced with the extension, is You-Shin Chen (sets), Paloma Young (costumes), Thom Weaver (lighting) and Palmer Hefferan (sound).
The piece has been built up over several seasons. It premiered at Hudson Valley Shakespeare in 2023, went on to Signature Theatre in Washington, DC, in 2024 and to Theatre Horizon, in association with Pennsylvania Shakespeare Festival, in 2025, the same year McLean led its first full production at The Ancram Center in New York. This year the American Academy of Arts and Letters gave it the 2026 Richard Rodgers Award for Best New Musical, just ahead of a sold-out run at the Edinburgh Fringe. Reviewing it there for The New York Times, Helen Shaw wrote that “Penelope is ready to thrive outside the Fringe’s peculiar hothouse ecology,” while Mark Fisher of The Guardian found McLean “drily witty, defiant, and elegant.” A cast album, Penelope: Live from Joe’s Pub, is out now on Joy Machine Records.
The production is presented in association with rigor + ruckus, and follows CSC’s staging of Waiting for Lefty, which has been extended through December 6.
CSC patrons can book the January performances from 12pm ET today, Friday, November 20, and the general on-sale follows on Tuesday, November 24, at 12pm ET. Penelope runs at CSC’s Lynn F. Angelson Theater, 136 East 13th Street, from December 10, 2026, to January 21, 2027. Book tickets for Penelope.








