Austin gets its first look at Peter Pan Goes Wrong this winter, and Zach Theater has found a Narrator who knows Neverland better than anyone: Cathy Rigby, who flew as Peter Pan for most of four decades. The production runs January 27 to February 28, 2027, on the Topfer stage at Zach.
Zach announced the casting on November 19. Cassie Abate, the company’s associate artistic director, directs, and the rest of the cast and the creative team are due to be named in December.
Rigby has played this Narrator before, in the La Mirada Theatre for the Performing Arts production in Southern California in 2025. The part she is known for came long before that. She first played Peter Pan in 1974, took the musical to Broadway in 1990 and earned a Tony nomination for it, and kept returning to the role on tour until her farewell run ended in 2013, some 3,000 performances in all. Before the stage, she was the highest-scoring American gymnast at the 1968 Olympics in Mexico City.
The comedy is the work of Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, the writers of The Play That Goes Wrong. Their hapless amateur company attempts J.M. Barrie’s Peter Pan and loses the fight with almost everything: rigging that will not fly on cue, scenery that comes apart, costumes with ideas of their own and a cast still arguing over who should have been given which part.
Performances run Wednesday through Sunday, with a Pride Night on Thursday, January 28, the Champagne Opening on Thursday, February 4, and a sign-interpreted matinee on Saturday, February 20. Zach recommends the show for ages 8 and up; it runs 2 hours 5 minutes with a 20-minute intermission. Tickets are sold through Zach Theater and its box office, 512-476-0541 ext. 1.







